Skip to content

November 16, 2026

“A free press is the guardian of a free society”

The Ashland Free Press
Collage on aged paper: a council dais with empty chairs and microphones, a brass balance scale on it tipped by a tall stack of signature sheets against a short one, and a clipboard petition hanging from the front with a pencil on a string and fingerless gloves. Above, a desk calendar with one date circled in red, a blank title strip ending in a question mark, and a ballot slip with an empty box under a red stamp. Residents watch from the seats, seen from behind.Art by CONTRA

The Sunday Edition

To Conform With Oregon Law

Item 2026-1189 starts on page 95 of the 521-page packet for Tuesday’s City Council meeting, somewhere between an airport lease and the contracts for the new water treatment plant. It is four ordinances sharing one public hearing. The City Recorder sent them up, and the staff report files them under the city’s “ongoing Municipal Code cleanup and modernization efforts.” The second is Ordinance No. 3313, and its title is “An Ordinance Amending AMC 2.36 Initiative and Referendum Procedures to Conform With Oregon Law.”

Read quickly, it supports two stories, and both are easy to tell. In one, the ordinance raises the share of voters needed to put a citizen measure on the ballot from ten percent to fifteen, about two thousand signatures where thirteen hundred used to do, pushed through by a council with seven weeks left to serve. In the other, fifteen percent is what Oregon requires of every city, Medford and Phoenix already use it, and Ashland is only catching up.

Ashland already asks for fifteen percent to start an initiative and ten to refer an ordinance to the voters. The ordinance keeps both numbers and changes what they are a percentage of, and on the voter rolls Jackson County used for the November election that change takes a citizen initiative from 1,308 signatures to 2,422.

The title is spurious. Oregon law lets a city use the state’s count and does not require it, and the staff report never mentions that the count is changing. The timing is worse. Two weeks ago Ashland voters approved Measure 15-243, a charter amendment that started as a citizen petition and requires a public vote before the city puts a new fee or tax on utility bills for something other than the utilities themselves, or raises one faster than inflation. Now the council is set to make the next petition 85 percent harder to qualify, under a title about tidying up, in a report that leaves the number out. Deciding things about the public without telling the public is the habit 15-243 was written to break.

Signatures, Number Required

That is the heading of Section 2.36.010 of the municipal code, and the paragraph under it is short. Signatures from qualified electors “equal to ten (10) percent of the total votes cast for Mayor at the last preceding City election” order a referendum on an ordinance the council has passed, and signatures equal to fifteen percent of the same total propose a measure by initiative. Ordinance 3313 strikes that paragraph and puts two in its place. A petition to refer a city measure must be signed by not less than ten percent “of the electors registered in the City at the time the prospective petition is filed,” and a petition to initiate one by not less than fifteen percent of the same. A prospective petition is the first filing in any petition drive, the one a chief petitioner hands the city before collecting a single signature.

In November 2024 Tonya Graham ran for mayor without an opponent. Jackson County’s precinct report gives her 8,083 votes and the write-ins 631, which is 8,714 votes for mayor out of 13,259 ballots cast in Ashland, and 4,543 Ashland voters left that line blank.

On November 3, 2025, the council split evenly on whether to send a charter amendment requiring a public vote on new utility-bill fees to the ballot itself. The mayor broke the tie against it, Ashland.news reported. The next evening George Kramer, who had written the amendment, stood at the public forum with a petition and told the council he expected to collect “the 1,308 signatures we need to put it on the May ballot.” Fifteen percent of 8,714 is 1,307.1, and the code says not less than, so the city asked for 1,308.

At the council meeting on July 21 of this year, Councilor Kaplan asked how a petition first reported at about 1,500 signatures had come out at 1,316. The city recorder said that when the sheets came in she had counted sheets, not signatures, and gone off the petitioners’ own figure of 1,537. “So I took 1,537, there were 194 electronic signature sheets. And that’s how I sort of mathed out the rest,” she said. When the petition reached the council, she and a colleague counted every name and found 1,316, eight more than required. The council voted 5–1 to send an amended version to the November ballot, where Measure 15-243 stood at 57.4 percent yes in the county’s November 10 count.

Under Ordinance 3313 the count is a share of everyone registered, and the county put Ashland’s registered voters at 16,143 for the November election. Fifteen percent of that is 2,422 signatures for an initiative, and ten percent is 1,615 for a referendum, where the rule in force today asks for 1,308 and 872. Both go up by about 85 percent. The rough figure of two thousand is low by more than four hundred, and the petition that put 15-243 on the ballot, with its 1,316 signatures, would have finished more than a thousand short.

The gap is this wide partly because the 2024 mayor’s race had one name on it. A contested race draws more votes, and more votes raise the old count. If every Ashland ballot cast in November 2024 had marked the mayor’s race, fifteen percent of 13,259 would have been 1,989.

Not More Than 15 Percent

Oregon’s constitution reserves the initiative and the referendum to the voters of every city, and Article IV, Section 1(5) says how much a city may ask of them.

“The manner of exercising those powers shall be provided by general laws, but cities may provide the manner of exercising those powers as to their municipal legislation. In a city, not more than 15 percent of the qualified voters may be required to propose legislation by the initiative, and not more than 10 percent of the qualified voters may be required to order a referendum on legislation.”

The fifteen and the ten are ceilings, and the sentence before them lets each city set its own procedure for its own laws. The legislature wrote its general laws into chapter 250 of the Oregon Revised Statutes, and ORS 250.305 is where the state’s figures live. Ordinance 3313 copies them almost word for word: ten percent of registered electors to refer a city measure, fifteen to initiate one, counted on the day the prospective petition is filed. The section that decides whether any of it applies to Ashland comes first, and it is one sentence long. ORS 250.255 says the city sections of the chapter, ORS 250.265 through 250.346, apply to a city measure “unless the city charter or ordinance provides otherwise.”

Ashland’s charter sets no number of its own. Article II, Section 3 lets voters petition for a charter election “under any initiative or referendum ordinance of the City of Ashland, or the laws of the State of Oregon,” and the ordinance it means is Chapter 2.36. So Ashland has written its own rule, at a count well under the constitution’s ceiling, and the state’s fifteen percent of registered voters is only what a city falls back on when it hasn’t. The Secretary of State’s manual for local petitions prints the state’s city figures, fifteen percent of registered voters to initiate and ten to refer, under a line that reads, “The following information may be superseded by local charter or ordinance.”

The confusion is not new. When the fee amendment first came before the council in October 2025, Ashland.news reported that, according to the Secretary of State’s website, Kramer “would have to get signatures from 15% of registered voters in Ashland,” which would have been about 2,400. The city asked him for 1,308.

Other cities wrote their own rules too, and several chose the base Ashland uses now. Eugene’s code sets an initiative at fifteen percent and a referendum at ten percent “of the number of votes cast for the office of mayor,” and Corvallis puts the same two numbers in its charter, counted against the votes cast for mayor at the last municipal election. Portland changed the base and lowered the numbers, to nine percent of registered voters for an initiative and six for a referendum. Medford and Phoenix, the two cities named in that second story, both keep their own initiative rules in their codes, Medford under a section headed “Number of Signatures.” What either one counts is unconfirmed.

“Do Not Diminish”

The staff report gives Ordinance 3313 three short paragraphs and four bullet points. The first bullet says the ordinance will “reference the Oregon Constitution and ORS Chapter 250 for signature thresholds and filing deadlines.” It does not reference them for the thresholds. It writes the state’s default numbers into Ashland’s code, where they will stay until a later council changes them, and it deletes the base the city has used until now. The report never mentions votes cast for mayor, registered voters or a number of signatures, and it closes with this.

“The proposed revisions do not diminish the initiative or referendum rights of Ashland voters. Rather, they provide a clearer and more legally sound framework for administering those rights.”

A right that takes 2,422 signatures to use where it took 1,308 has been diminished by 1,114 signatures. The report gives Item 2026-1189 a time estimate of thirty minutes for all four ordinances and a fiscal impact of none, and a councilor who read only the report would have no way to know the number had moved. Neither would a resident who read the title, which says the ordinance conforms the city to a law that Ashland’s rule already satisfies.

The old paragraph does have a real fault. Ashland elects a mayor every four years and councilors every two, so for half of every four-year cycle “the last preceding City election” is one with no mayor’s race on the ballot. This is one of those halves. Since November 3 the last city election has been one in which no votes at all were cast for mayor, and read literally, which is how a petition opponent’s lawyer would read it, the rule now asks for fifteen percent of zero. Fixing that takes a phrase, and Eugene’s code already has one, counting the votes cast for mayor “at the mayoral election last preceding the date when circulation of the petition begins.” Swapping in the state’s sentence fixes it too and costs 1,114 signatures, and a staff report that said so would have given the council the choice.

The rest of the ordinance is the cleanup the report describes, and nobody has much reason to object to it. It drops a filing deadline of eighty-eight days before a regular election, a sixty-three-day rule for special elections and a ninety-three-day rule for referendum elections, all of which the state has long since replaced, and points instead to ORS chapters 250 and 254. It sets the window for a referendum at thirty days after the council adopts an ordinance, before it takes effect. It strikes the old line excusing the city from printing a voters’ pamphlet. And it keeps the city’s power to put advisory questions on the ballot, by council resolution or by petition.

Matters in Which the Public Is Not Interested

The cleanup walked past one paragraph without touching it. Section 2.36.030 requires whoever files an initiative or referendum petition to hand the City Recorder cash or a certified check in an amount the council sets by resolution. If the measure loses, the city pays for the election out of the deposit and returns whatever is left. If it wins, the petitioners get it all back and the city pays. The section ends with a sentence of the kind nobody has written in a municipal code for a long time.

“This provision is made for the purpose of preventing the depletion of City funds by elections on matters in which the public is not interested and which have no merit.”

Ordinance 3313 strikes the voters’ pamphlet clause, the special election clause and three deadlines, and leaves this sentence where it was.

First Reading

City staff first brought a list of municipal code updates to a council study session on November 17, 2025. The council’s work group had Chapter 2.36 on its agenda on September 8 of this year, and the city has posted that agenda and nothing else from the meeting. The council’s October calendar of upcoming business put the first reading on November 17 and the second reading on December 1, and under Article X of the charter an ordinance takes effect on the thirtieth day after it is enacted, which would be the last day of December.

The councilors the voters chose on November 3 take their seats in January. The county’s count has Bob Kaplan, Dan Ruby, Teresa Cisneros and Linda Adams in the four open places, and Jeff Dahle, Eric Hansen and Derek Sherrell, who did not run, leave. If the calendar holds, the second reading on December 1 is the last vote this council casts on the rules the public uses to go over its head, and three of the six people casting it are on their way out.

The work group took up Chapter 2.36 in September, before the election, so the ordinance was not written as an answer to the vote count. That is the most that can be said for the timing. It was reviewed while 15-243 was on the ballot, it was never described to the public as a change in the signature count, and it is scheduled to pass in the weeks between the voters’ answer and the seating of the council they elected. A city that wanted the public to notice would have put the numbers on the first page of the staff report.

Some readers have wondered whether this is about the food and beverage tax, which runs out at the end of 2030. It is hard to see how. A council that wants to renew a tax refers it to the ballot by its own vote, and a referral needs no signatures at all. What the new count makes harder is a petition the council did not ask for, either to put a measure on the ballot or to send one of its ordinances there.

Why the base changed, the report does not say. We can only guess, and the likeliest guess is the dull one: somebody noticed the old sentence breaks down every other election, reached for the state’s sentence because the state’s sentence never breaks down, and did not run the numbers. That would explain a staff report that mentions no numbers.

Public Hearing

Tuesday’s meeting begins at six in the council chambers at 1175 East Main Street, and Item 2026-1189 is a public hearing, which means anyone may speak to it. The city’s online public comment form takes requests to speak and written comments until 10 a.m. on the day of the meeting.

The council should fix the sentence it has. Keep fifteen percent and ten percent of the votes cast for mayor, and say which election, so that the count can never fall to zero and never jumps by 1,114 signatures because of a cleanup. Pass the rest of Ordinance 3313, the deadlines and the pamphlet and the pointers to state law, because that part is what the title says it is. As for the signature count, call it what it is: a higher bar for citizen petitions, brought by an outgoing council two weeks after the voters used a petition to take a power away from it. If a majority wants that bar, it can vote for it in an ordinance whose title says so, with the numbers in the staff report and the second reading left to the council that takes office in January. And the report’s line about rights not being diminished should be struck before anyone votes.

The people a petition count lands on are the ones holding the clipboards in January, asking strangers on the sidewalk whether they are registered to vote inside the city limits. Last winter 1,316 of those strangers said yes and signed, and it was enough by eight. The next group should be told the truth about how many more it will need, and that number should be decided by the council the voters just picked.


Sources: The ordinance, its struck and added text and the staff report are in the city’s packet for the November 17 business meeting, pages 95 to 104, and the September 8 work group agenda and the October look-ahead calendar are the city’s own. The law is the Oregon Constitution, Article IV, Section 1(5), and ORS 250.255 and 250.305 as the Legislature publishes them, with the Secretary of State’s County, City, and District Initiative and Referendum Manual, revised January 2024. Ashland’s charter is quoted from the copy the city printed in its January 2025 council training binder. The vote counts are Jackson County’s: the official precinct report for November 2024, summed across the Ashland precincts, and the unofficial count of November 10, 2026, which can still move by a few votes before the county certifies it. The registered-voter total changes every day, and the ordinance counts it on the day a prospective petition is filed, so 2,422 and 1,615 are the counts as of the November rolls and the next petition’s will differ a little. Eugene’s, Corvallis’s and Portland’s rules are from their published codes and charters, and the piece leaves open what Medford and Phoenix count, as it says. Measure 15-243 is described from its title on the county’s ballot and the inflation allowance the council wrote into it in July. The Kramer and recorder quotations are from the machine-generated captions of the November 4, 2025 and July 21, 2026 council meetings. Quotations appear as transcribed, and names are attached only where the record confirms the speaker. Where a summary of the law disagrees with the law, including the staff report’s summary and the state’s website as Ashland.news relayed it in 2025, this piece follows the text of the law. George Kramer, who wrote the 15-243 petition, also wrote this paper’s Sunday edition of October 11.