# TRAILS, Bellview, Willow Wind: Close None on This Record

*Opinion · November 20, 2026 · by Nixie Worthington*

> The School Board spent its November 19 meeting asking nothing about closing TRAILS. The district's own FAQ says the comparison that would justify closing it and keeping Willow Wind is unfinished, five of eleven speakers asked the board to pause, and by Friday night 425 people had signed a petition to save TRAILS.

---

On November 19 the Ashland School Board reached Item 12, the proposal to close Bellview and TRAILS, marked "no action," and the board took no interest in it either. Superintendent Joseph Hattrick reported on what the district had heard at two town halls, said a third night of the full presentation would be redundant, and opened the floor to the board. In the recording nobody on the dais asked him anything. The chair went straight to public comment. Two schools are proposed to close and not one board member had a question about either.

Hattrick said the town halls produced 825 submitted questions. He listed what families keep asking, and the first item was why the proposal treats Bellview, TRAILS and Willow Wind differently. He promised his recommendation would say how the feedback shaped it and gave no date. He did not say whether the district will publish a comparison of the schools, which is what families were asking for.

Assistant Superintendent Michelle Cuddeback answered a different question, how a grade-banded setup can cost less than two K–5 schools. She said the savings were counted when the committee chose two elementary schools over three, and cost stopped steering the choice after that. The $4.834 million is the subject of [Fourth-Grade Math](/the-sunday-edition/2026-11-18-fourth-grade-math) and the meeting added nothing to it. The banded schools got an answer. The question about TRAILS and Willow Wind, first on the superintendent's own list, got none. Apart from that list, nobody on the dais named either school while the proposal was on the table.

The chair did move the December meeting back a week, to Thursday, December 17, tentatively in the City Council Chamber, which may already be booked. Speakers had been calling it the December 10 vote.

I think closing TRAILS is a mistake, and I thought so before I looked at a single number. I am angrier now that I have looked. The district wants to close a school of 114 students on a savings figure that no public document explains, with Thanksgiving in the way, and it has not put that school next to the one it is keeping. Willow Wind did not write the proposal. Some of its families wrote to this paper that it is the reason they stayed in the district, and they are owed the same comparison as everyone else.

## Show Us the Numbers

Eleven people spoke, two minutes each, including a second grader who asked not to be split from a little brother. Five asked the board to pause or slow down.

The most specific request came from a parent who teaches sixth-grade math at the middle school. She asked for one verified side-by-side comparison of every site, Willow Wind included: test scores, attendance, IEP and 504 enrollment, per-pupil cost, enrollment trends and more. She also wanted the number of inquiry forms sent to Willow Wind and not only its waiting list.

A TRAILS parent said the 2024–25 figures she found put TRAILS about $2,000 a student below the other alternative school, and asked the board to consider the TRAILS community's own plan to keep two K–5 neighborhood schools. The district's FAQ says TRAILS costs nearly 12 percent more. Somebody is counting differently or is wrong, and the district could tell us which in a sentence.

A parent who is an epidemiologist said she read the proposal, found no data in it, and filed a public-records request that day for the data underneath. She said such requests can take 35 days. Thirty-five days from November 19 is December 24, a week after the board is scheduled to meet. Several speakers said the notice was too short.

The FAQ, printed with the proposal on November 16, concedes the speakers are right. A full answer on why TRAILS would close and Willow Wind would stay, the district writes, "requires comparative costs, enrollment, service delivery and educational purpose," and the verified comparison "remains an important supporting record for the recommendation." Councilor Dylan Bloom, writing as a councilor and a parent, wants the board to wait for it and hold every school to it, the lottery included.

## Four Hundred Twenty-Five Signatures, Two Days In

A petition called SAVE TRAILS OUTDOOR SCHOOL went up on change.org on Wednesday, November 18. At 10:26 p.m. Pacific on Friday, November 20, it showed 425 signatures. KOBI-TV had 407 at 5:02 that afternoon. The page says 68 percent of signers are in the 97520 ZIP code, which is Ashland. It lists 20 comments and displayed 19, so this describes 19.

<aside class="afp-callout" aria-label="Petition"><p class="afp-callout__kicker">Petition</p><p class="afp-callout__text">A petition called <em>SAVE TRAILS OUTDOOR SCHOOL</em> is collecting signatures. It asks the School Board to postpone the vote and answer the questions about the numbers.</p><p class="afp-callout__go"><a href="https://www.change.org/p/save-trails-outdoor-school" target="_blank" rel="noopener">See the petition on change.org &rarr;</a></p></aside>

Every comment is on TRAILS's side, and the mood is grief and gratitude more than rage. Most are a parent, grandparent or former student describing what the school did for a child. "My son has thrived at TRAILS school," Anna wrote. Nicole, a former education assistant, called it "a one-of-a-kind gem in the Rogue Valley." Candy wrote that children who hike, backpack and camp in snow come away thinking "I can do hard things." Madison, who went when it was John Muir, wrote that it "adds more to the community than it takes." Julie asked that TRAILS "remain a k-8 opportunity like willow wind" and conceded it is "already small with combined classes." Andrew wrote that "Trails is the reason we moved to Ashland," and a family that moves here for a school is a family the state pays for.

None of the 19 mentions the $4.834 million, per-pupil cost or Bellview. A petition is not a poll. The signers picked themselves, the page calls the signatures verified without saying against what, and 425 is under four times the 114 students the proposal says TRAILS has. The petition says 25 percent of families voted to keep choice schools. The proposal's figure is 26 percent of survey respondents who prioritized preserving choice programs, and it does not print the share who prioritized neighborhood schools. Neither is a vote.

Board Chair Russell Hatch gave KOBI the district's side. TRAILS is valued, he said, the district is looking for a footprint that preserves choice, and there are far fewer children in the district than there used to be. "TRAILS, unfortunately, has been shrinking year over year for quite a while," he said, and he called the process "painful" and "really difficult math." That is a fair point, but it does not justify closing this school and keeping that one. The petition's lead petitioner, Heather Vidrine, who has two children at TRAILS, told KOBI: "We deserve data, we deserve numbers. The proposal does not have that." The sixth-grade math teacher asked for the same thing at the podium.

## Four Bullets

Under the header "Why TRAILS and not Willow Wind Community Learning Center?" the FAQ gives four reasons. TRAILS "has a nearly 12% higher per pupil cost to operate than Willow Wind." It "has our lowest enrollment at the current time." The proposal cites "an interest in maintaining components of the TRAILS model and outdoor education," to be worked into the curriculum later by an implementation team. And the "Willow Wind site can be leveraged as a natural location for outdoor education use."

Nobody outside the district can test the 12 percent. State school-level spending reports do not list Willow Wind as its own school, and on those reports TRAILS costs less per student than Bellview or Helman. Whether it costs more than Willow Wind is in the district's books, and the FAQ admits those are not finished. The district has told TRAILS families their school costs too much and cannot show them the arithmetic.

Low enrollment is the strongest of the four. A K–8 school with 114 children is small, and a district losing students has to look at small schools. Shrinking is a reason to ask why and what to do about it. The district's answer is to remove the school. Promising to keep pieces of TRAILS by handing them to a team that has not met does not make up for that.

## As of the First School Day in October

Willow Wind is a K–8 public alternative program. It has full-time students and registered homeschool students who attend part time, and not every student is homeschooled. The district looked at closing Willow Wind and TRAILS together and rejected it, because projected 2030–31 enrollment would force another consolidation and leave two K–5 schools "without a flexible alternative program at the elementary level." TRAILS is a public alternative program too. The passage says why the district wants one alternative. It never says why one is enough.

The November 19 enrollment report counts the first school day in October and puts Willow Wind at 207 full-time and 32 part-time. The chart beside it shows 209 full-time the year before, the figure in Bloom's post. Bellview is 239 full-time and one part-time. The October 8 packet describes the same October with Bellview at 242 full-time and a footnote of 34 part-time homeschool students at Willow Wind. The November 19 packet adds a November count with Bellview at 238, Willow Wind at 206 and the same footnote of 34. That is three counts of Bellview within four students of each other, and two of Willow Wind's part-time students, in a proposal that means to choose between schools on enrollment.

At the meeting the director of student services said every school has shrunk since 2018 except Willow Wind, which has grown. Keeping a program families are still filling is a coherent position, and Willow Wind families did nothing wrong by filling it. The district still has to defend that position with the same numbers it uses against TRAILS.

## A Good Placement for the Student

Willow Wind's admissions page still begins with an inquiry form. Families "will meet with an administrative representative for an interview to determine if the program is a good placement for the student," and students "will be evaluated for acceptance according to selection criteria, which includes a case management review." If the school is full, "a lottery will be held for each area of priority on the waiting list."

The November 16 proposal describes a different front door: "All students residing within Ashland School District boundaries (including those with disabilities) are eligible to apply for, and participate in the Willow Wind lottery which is managed through the Student Services Department." One is the district's rule and the other is a page that still says "his/her" and "IEP's." The page may just be old. A district deciding which school to close should not be describing the other one from an old page.

A school that interviews for fit and a school that drops every resident into a drawing do not cost the same. A full roster at one says nothing about the other. Before 207 counts as demand, the district should say which door is open and publish applicants, admissions and the waiting list by the priority categories the page already uses. The teacher at the podium also asked for the count of inquiries, which shows how many families the interview or the lottery turned away.

Bloom wrote that he has heard from families who believe children on IEPs and 504 plans were discouraged from enrolling at Willow Wind or staying. On November 19 a parent told the board she had been told her child would not thrive there and need not apply. A TRAILS parent said TRAILS does not discriminate against students with IEPs and put their share there between 15 and 30 percent. These are accounts, and nothing in the board's record confirms any of them. The packet prints special-education counts for neither school, and I would put the same question to TRAILS in the same room.

Willow Wind's own special-education page says special education services or the majority of related services "are not offered on site." For Ashland residents, "evaluations and services for special education occur through your neighborhood school," and "Parents generally provide transportation" to those services. The same page says the school offers "most accommodations to any child that needs them, so 504 plans with individualized accommodations are often not needed."

A specialist who works at Bellview and is paid on Bellview's books makes Willow Wind look cheaper per pupil and Bellview look dearer than its classrooms are. The FAQ's cost bullet does not say whose budget holds the salary.

## Eleven Percent of ADM

Bloom's post says the state funds students on IEPs and 504 plans at a higher rate up to a cap of 11 percent, and that Ashland sits at 14 percent. ORS 327.013 gives a weight of 1.0 to a student eligible for special education, and that extra weight may not exceed 11 percent of the district's average daily membership unless the Department of Education approves a waiver, which the department says does not automatically cover every student above the line.

The October snapshot in the November 19 packet puts special education at 13.3 percent of students and 504 plans at 8.5 percent, on separate lines. It does not say whether part-time students are counted, does not give the average daily membership the statute uses, and nowhere prints 14 percent. Whether 13.3 percent of an October headcount is over 11 percent of ADM depends on a calculation the packet does not contain. The district may be right that it has more students above the line than the state pays for. I would like to see the line.

The 32 part-time homeschool students sit outside the 207. Unpublished are what the state pays for each one and whether that revenue sits inside the per-pupil cost that puts TRAILS nearly 12 percent above Willow Wind. The district has published no estimate of how many families would leave, and the earlier piece has the arithmetic on how few departures it takes to spend the savings.

## Before a Vote

The board meets next on Thursday, December 17. The survey closes Sunday, December 6, eleven days earlier, and the proposal says the board will act in December.

This paper is against closing TRAILS on this record and would say the same about Willow Wind on the same record. The district should publish the comparison its FAQ calls a supporting record, for every school, Willow Wind included, from one October count, and publish it before the survey closes so families can read it before they answer. It should reconcile Bellview at 238, 239 and 242 and Willow Wind's part-time count at 32 and 34. It should charge special-education services to the school that delivers them in a cost-per-pupil table, and show the 12 percent or withdraw it. It should print the lottery in numbers: inquiries, applicants, admissions, waiting list. It should say whether the interview and case-management review still decide who gets in, how many students sit above 11 percent of ADM, whether it holds a waiver, and what the state pays for part-time students. And it should print special-education and 504 counts and outcomes for Willow Wind beside Bellview and TRAILS.

I am angry that the district put a school's future up for a December vote without saying what it costs next to the one it is keeping. Take the closures off the calendar until the comparison is in the board packet. The chair moved the December meeting back a week on Thursday night, so the calendar can move, and 425 people have already asked for the time.

---

*Sources: the Ashland School Board's November 19, 2026 regular session as recorded by Rogue Valley Television, and its agenda and packet; the October 8, 2026 packet; the Ashland School District's Community Transformation Proposal and FAQ of November 16, 2026; Willow Wind's admissions and special-education pages on the district site; the ORS 327.013 as the Oregon Department of Education explains it; and Councilor Dylan Bloom's public post. The petition is SAVE TRAILS OUTDOOR SCHOOL on change.org, as its page stood at 10:26 p.m. Pacific on Friday, November 20, 2026. The 407 signatures and the remarks of Board Chair Russell Hatch and the lead petitioner are as KOBI-TV reported them in a story by Ripley Pierotti published at 5:02 p.m. that day. Commenters appear by the first name the page shows, their comments were not checked, and the page does not say what the signatures were verified against. The $4.834 million is as [Fourth-Grade Math](/the-sunday-edition/2026-11-18-fourth-grade-math) laid it out. The meeting's minutes are not yet approved, so no roll call is stated. Machine transcription garbles names, so nothing said at the meeting is quoted and private speakers are not named. What speakers said about cost, IEP shares, records-request timing and being told not to apply is as said and not confirmed by these documents, nor are accounts of children discouraged from the program. December 24 is the paper's arithmetic on a speaker's 35 days. The judgment is mine.*

Source: https://ashlandfreepress.com/opinion/2026-11-20-why-trails-and-not-willow-wind