# The Reason Keeps Changing

*Opinion · August 4, 2026 · by Nixie Worthington*

> A $6,000 rafter, five explanations for one locked City Hall, a roofer with a live warranty who never got a call, a police car in a journalist's driveway, and thirty Helman heirs with four lawyers.

Art by CONTRA — Collage: photos of City Hall and the Ashland Community Center under a shifting stack of taped tracing-paper rooflines, each sketch a different shape, one bar blacked out.

---

The Ashland Community Center was closed for seven years, and it closed in 2019.
The city paid Outlier Construction more than $2.2 million for the Community
Center and Pioneer Hall together, and through all seven of those years there
were no weddings in it, no memorials, no public anything.

It reopened in February 2026. The first people through the door were thirteen
city employees, including City Manager Sabrina Cotta, who took an office.

There was no ribbon cutting, no grand opening, no tour. The ribbon cutting was
eventually scheduled for July 22, five months after the government moved in,
and the sequence is the whole argument. The building was not opened to the
public and then borrowed by staff in an emergency. It was occupied by staff,
and the public was invited to its own building afterward.

Councilor Gina DuQuenne said it plainly: "After seven years, no community events
had been there, no ceremonies, no memorials, no celebrations. The first thing
that happened was for the city to move into the community center without a grand
opening, a ribbon cutting, a tour or anything. To me, that was not acceptable."

## The Inspection That Was Not Looking For This

Start with why City Hall closed, because the origin of the inspection is the
part nobody mentions.

On January 16, 2026, a building inspector from Oregon Commercial Property
Inspections went through City Hall. The city had commissioned that report, and
here is the detail, as part of its legal proceedings to obtain clear title to
the building. Communications Director Dorinda Cottle confirmed as much to
Ashland.news. The city went looking for ammunition in a lawsuit and came back
with a condemnation notice.

Fire Marshal Mark Shay's own report, filed February 17 at three in the
afternoon, records how it reached him: "As the fire code official, I was
provided a copy of the report by City Manager Cotta."

Shay found two deficiencies. First, "a split rafter in the upstairs attic,"
described in the inspection as "an approximate 2x6 structural member that is
split into two pieces." Second, multiple concerns with the roof, which he quotes
directly: "extreme granule lost with several past patch work," "areas of
buckling," "decay and in disrepair," "staining and holes in roof with damaged
plywood / beams / timber," and "subfloor with holes caused by moisture via
roof."

He called the city manager. "Upon review of the report I contacted City Manager
Cotta and expressed my concern regarding structural stability of the roof. With
the combination of the split rafter and multiple identified areas of concern to
the roofing system, it is unknown the full extent of damage."

Then the sentence that has been almost entirely absent from the public
conversation ever since:

"A report by a qualified engineer assessing the safety of the roof system should
be forwarded to Fire Marshal Shay prior to resuming normal occupancy."

Not *replace the roof*, not *spend $260,000*. An engineer's report on the roof
system. That was the stated condition of reopening, set by the official with
the statutory power to set it, in writing, on February 17.

Shay's report also does something the city's messaging has never acknowledged.
It lays out how staff may keep using the building in the meantime: no entry
with snow or ice on the roof, when clear, anyone entering is tracked by a
responsible party who stays outside, the log records "name, time in, time out
and purpose", limit the number of occupants at one time, keep visits to a few
minutes.

That is a fire marshal managing a risk while an engineer takes a look, not a
man condemning a structure.

Councilor Dylan Bloom — the only elected official who answered The Chronicle's
questions in February, which is its own small indictment of the other six — made
the fair defense: the fire marshal has independent statutory authority in Oregon,
the decision "is not discretionary for Council or the City Manager," and a
municipal building is not a house where you call a guy.

He is right, but the closure was not Cotta's call. Everything after it was.

## Six Thousand Dollars, And Then Everything Else

The split rafter was repaired. The city's own repair table, dated March 25, 2026
and attached to the May 4 council packet, carries it as a line item:

**Rafter Repair (Safety), $6,000.** Staff estimate. The Chronicle reported the
actual cost at $5,700.

A roofing expert consulted by The Chronicle described the fix as
straightforward: supports on both sides of the split, or a steel brace if
needed. A consulting firm advised that reopening was possible once it was done.

City Hall did not reopen. Cotta announced instead: "Staff will not be returning
until we get the roof fixed."

The same table prices the roof. Under Immediate Concerns, "Roofing (Life
Cycle)" comes to **$260,000**. Add electrical, HVAC, water heater and pest
control and the immediate total is **$516,613**. Keep going — seismic
structural updates at $2,472,355, sprinklers, exit signage, masonry, windows,
generator, doors, drainage, interior finishes — and the full City Hall list
totals **$3,412,037**, before ADA accommodation or asbestos planning, which the
table says it excludes.

Also in that packet: a proposal from Hoag Roofing dated April 24, 2026, to let
the roof dry for 48 hours and apply a silicone coating over the existing PVC
membrane. Material and labor complete, the sum of **$23,778.18**, with a
five-year manufacturer's material warranty.

So the menu of responses to a leaking roof over two offices ran from about
twenty-four thousand dollars to three and a half million. The city chose none of
them, and the building sat empty.

I am not against fixing the roof properly. The 2024 McKinstry report said it had
exceeded its useful life, and Bloom is right that piecemeal spending on a
building with no long-term plan is how cities waste money.

It is simply not the argument anyone was making in February. In February this
was a $6,000 rafter and a request for an engineer's report.

## The Phone Call Nobody Made

The roof on Ashland City Hall carries a warranty, and the warranty has years
left to run.

Blesser Built Roofing of Medford did the work. The Chronicle reports the
current roof went on in 2013 under a twenty-year manufacturer's materials
guarantee. At the May 4 study session a councilor, reading from paperwork in
open session, described it slightly differently, partial roof work in 2014, for
$8,000, under a twenty-year warranty with twelve years still to run. The date
and the scope are not settled and I am not going to pretend otherwise.

What is not in dispute is the part that matters. There is a warranty, it is
live, and the councilor reading those documents noted something else: Blesser
was not among the firms asked to quote on the repairs.

On April 7, the City Council directed staff to obtain bids or quotes for
repairing or replacing the roof and for the HVAC.

In late June, nearly three months later, The Chronicle asked Ryan Blesser
whether the city had contacted him about the leaks keeping City Hall closed.

His entire answer was one word. "No."

He added that the roof he put on that historic building is under a guarantee he
stands by.

Three months. A live warranty, a company twelve miles up the interstate, a
council directive, a councilor who found the paperwork by looking, and the
easiest telephone call in municipal government was not made. Meanwhile the rain
came in April and May, into a building nobody was allowed to enter, and how
much further damage that did is unknown, because nobody was in there.

Asked in late June what had been done to carry out the April 7 direction, Cottle
referred the question to Public Works Director Scott Fleury, who was on
vacation.

## What The Leaks Are Doing, According To The City

Cotta declared City Hall would not reopen on account of leaks in the roof, over
two offices. Her own, and that of Human Resources Director Molly Taylor.

Here is Fleury, on the record in late June, on those leaks: there has been no
significant water damage to the offices since Cotta and Taylor decamped to the
Community Center.

And here is Cottle, in the same reporting, offering a third rationale: the
repairs are unbudgeted and need council approval, and "if City Council approves
those projects, it'll be easiest for the contractors to perform the work — and
for staff to avoid disruption — with staff not in the building." Plus a fourth:
"There is also the pending litigation over City Hall's encumbered title, which
can also influence how and what the City does with the building."

Line them up, in order of appearance.

February: a split rafter and a fire marshal asking for an engineer's report.
Repaired, $6,000. March onward: roof leaks over the city manager's office. Late
June: no significant water damage from those leaks, per public works. Also late
June: it is really about unbudgeted roof and HVAC work, which council must
approve, the same council that asked for the numbers on April 7 and received
nothing. Also late June: it is really about the lawsuit.

Five explanations, and one closed building. Any one of them might be true. They
cannot all be the reason, and the residents of this town are entitled to know
which one it is, from the person who made the call.

## A Friday At Two O'Clock

Meanwhile, thirteen people were sitting in the Community Center.

Councilor Bloom, with Councilor DuQuenne, called a special council meeting for
two o'clock on Friday, March 27, and opened by naming the point at the center of
this entire mess.

"It is understood, I think, that we all on council understand that operational
decisions are made by the city manager, but it is this council's responsibility
to make policy decisions. And my understanding is that we have been making
policy decisions about the community center."

Where to park displaced staff for a fortnight is operations. Converting a $2
million public building the council spent seven years reopening into
administrative offices is policy, one requires a phone call, the other requires
a vote.

There was no vote. Councilors got an emergency alert on February 16 about a
cracked rafter and an email on the 17th or 18th telling them all staff had been
moved into the Community Center. The council business meeting that would have
been the obvious place to discuss it had been canceled for snow.

Councilor Eric Hansen framed it in a sentence: "We're taking something away
from the community by occupying it with staff", and started listing
alternatives aloud: other city buildings, rented space, and, drily, the fact
that the Black Sheep is open. Deputy City Manager Jordan Rooklyn answered
capably, noting 2200 Ashland Street was the only city-owned building with that
much empty office space, and then said the thing that defined the afternoon:
"with the city manager out of town, I would definitely want her input."

The city manager was out of town. She was not available for the special meeting
called about her own decision.

Former Mayor Julie Akins told the council they were elected to represent "the
people of flesh and bone to whom you swore an oath," and that their job was to
"open public buildings to the public, inform the staff that they serve you and
serve the people."

The council voted 5-1 to ban the use of the Community Center as office space.

By May, Cotta was back before the council asking to stay, and the council
walked back the immediate ending, allowing staff to occupy the "historic office
areas" so long as they did not displace public rentals or programming. At the
end of June, staff were still there. The rental calendar had no opening date,
because the city was waiting on new door locks, for the offices that were
staying.

The public could not book the Community Center because the locks had not arrived
for the government offices inside it.

## The Doors Were Open. A Citizen Closed Them.

On a Sunday evening in late May, around 6:30, the doors of the Ashland Community
Center were standing wide open.

Jim Falkenstein found them. Falkenstein posts a report on social media about
every single City Council meeting, which makes him, in every sense that matters,
a member of the press in this town. He was with Marcus Scott, manager of the
Lithia Artisans Market. They went in, spent about two minutes, filmed what they
saw, came out, and locked the building.

That is the whole offense.

On Wednesday, Beth Falkenstein came home from the grocery store to find an
Ashland police car in her driveway. Officer Fisher was there for her husband.
Jim was out, so she called him and held the phone out so the officer could speak
to him.

It was not a thank-you. It was a warning about trespassing on city property,
but no charges were filed.

Beth Falkenstein was upset, reasonably, about a police car parked in front of
her house where the neighbors could see it.

Nobody will say who sent it. Police Chief Tighe O'Meara told The Chronicle it
wasn't him and that it didn't come from the Police Department. Cotta told
Ashland.news it wasn't her. Mayor Tonya Graham did not respond. Council
President Jeff Dahle said he didn't know, called it "a very high priority to
clearly understand exactly what occurred and who was involved in the
decision-making process," and promised to be transparent once he had verified
the facts, which is the most anyone in city government has offered.

An officer of the Ashland Police Department drove to a private residence to warn
a journalist, and the mayor, the police chief and the city manager have all
indicated it was not them. Someone ordered it. That person still has not been
named.

To their credit, and I mean this, Graham and Dahle put out a statement taking
the underlying blame: "Last weekend, a door at the Community Center was found
unlocked and wide open. This should not have happened, and the responsibility
rests squarely with the City. It is our job to ensure our facilities are
secure, and we fell short of that. No excuses." They thanked the community
members who secured the door.

That was the right statement, and it lasted about a week.

## "I Would Feel Violated"

On June 1, Mayor Graham escalated.

In a statement posted online, she wrote that by filming the offices and posting
his report, Falkenstein had violated the privacy of Cotta and Taylor.

"It has struck me as I've thought about this situation that city staff who had
their offices filmed and broadcast across social media likely feel violated in
much the same way as someone whose home privacy has been violated. I keep
personal photos and other things that have meaning for me at my desk, and I know
how I would feel if someone entered my office, filmed it, and posted it to
social media without my knowledge. I would feel violated."

She then asked the community to move on.

Falkenstein said he opened no drawers and no file cabinets in his two minutes
inside. "I didn't look at anything, not even a piece of paper." The camera
panned the offices and did not linger on anything personal.

I want to take the mayor's point seriously, because it contains a real human
truth: people keep their lives on their desks, and being filmed without warning
is unpleasant.

And then I want to say the obvious thing, flatly.

"Home" is the wrong word. That is the Ashland Community Center: a public
building, paid for by the public, closed to the public for seven years,
renovated with better than $2 million of public money, occupied by the city
administration without a public vote, over the objection of a 5-1 council,
while the residents who own it could not book it for a wedding.

The city left it standing open on a Sunday night, and a citizen closed it. The
city sent a police officer to his house. The mayor then explained that the
citizen had violated the privacy of the officials who should not have been in
the building in the first place, and asked everyone to move on.

The word "violated" is doing an enormous amount of work in that statement, and
it is pointed in exactly the wrong direction.

## The Ghost Of Abel Helman

One more thing, because it is the most Ashland item in this entire account, and
because it may end up mattering more than the roof.

In November 2025 the city filed suit in Jackson County Circuit Court seeking a
declaratory judgment to quiet the title to City Hall and a large portion of the
Plaza, including the lithia fountain. City Attorney Johan Pietila signed it.
His argument is that Ashland cannot move forward with selling or repairing City
Hall until ownership of the land is settled, which is a reasonable thing for a
city attorney to want.

The encumbrance is 142 years old. In 1884 John R. and Mary Helman deeded the
land to the town of Ashland for use as a "public Square or Plaza and also for
the erection of a Town Hall and Jail therein." If those uses stop, the property
reverts to the Helmans. The jail, small, out of compliance with state law, has
not held anyone since the 1970s and is now a storage room.

The city's position is that the reversionary clause is dead. It cites ORS
105.620, effective January 1, 1990, which offers a path to full title after ten
years of possession. Pietila has asked the court to declare that Ashland may use
the property "for any lawful purpose it chooses, including sale of the Property
to a third party."

Then the heirs showed up.

Nearly thirty descendants of John R. and Mary Helman have come forward and hired
four lawyers. Twenty-three were named in filings, with more to be added. Medford
attorney Deborah Vincent represents Robert Dayle Cox of Lynchburg, Virginia,
among others. On the same Friday the council voted 5-1 to get the government out
of the Community Center, six descendants filed a counterclaim.

Their argument is narrower and sharper than the city seems to have expected.
The deed, they write, "does not require continuous incarceration use of the
jail facilities, nor does it prohibit the City from utilizing alternative
correctional facilities." Ashland did not stop having a jail, but it started
using somebody else's. And then the sting: the building's *closure* may itself
violate the deed, which could require the city to return the property or
compensate the family. One of their attorneys has said the heirs are entitled
to just compensation for the value of the reversionary interest.

Follow the sequence, because it is nearly perfect. The city commissioned a
building inspection to strengthen its title lawsuit, and the inspection closed
the building. The closure may have handed the heirs their best argument.

There is one more number, and it belongs here rather than in the repair column.
In February the city had City Hall appraised. Colette Meyer, MAI, valued it as
of February 3 at **$280,000**, a figure built not from the building but from
4,771 square feet of land at $58 a foot, precisely because, as the appraisal
states, "due to the deed restriction which runs with the land, legally
permissible uses are municipal only for public square of the plaza, town hall
or jail." The building itself, 7,745 square feet raised in 1891 and extended in
1913 and 1995, is "in poor condition" and, "without renovation," at "the end of
its economic life."

Two hundred and eighty thousand dollars. The rafter and the roof alone come to
$266,000. The full repair list is more than twelve times the appraised value.
Estimated marketing period, should the city ever be free to sell: twelve to
twenty-four months.

Vincent has also asked the question that ought to be keeping the finance
department awake: "Why would anyone buy bonds if a reversionary clause is on
the property?" She adds that she agrees Ashland needs a new City Hall, just not
on the Plaza, which has limited parking and limited room for staff. Which is to
say that opposing counsel and the city's own facilities consultants have
reached roughly the same conclusion from opposite directions.

The case may be decided on the record by Judge Benjamin Bloom, or settled, and
settlement talks have reportedly run aground on the same rock as everything else
here: nobody can agree what the building is for.

Vincent, asked what her clients want, gave the most human answer anyone has
offered in this affair. "I think they are considering what their
great-great-grandfather did and what his goals were."

Two councilors, Dylan Bloom and Jeff Dahle, have said publicly they do not want
the building sold. "I get the sense that nobody wants to tear it down and build
something new," Bloom said. Dahle: "There are people who don't want to see the
building sold off, and I'm one of them."

So the city is in court arguing for the right to sell a building that at least
two of its councilors will not vote to sell, against thirty relatives who want
it kept as a town hall, in order to be free to repair it, while it sits closed
over a roof nobody has called the roofer about.

## And The Windows

Former City Councilor Eric Navickas appears to be the only person in Ashland who
reads the whole code. He located a provision holding that street-facing windows
"shall not be tinted so as to prevent views from outside of the building into
the interior of the building."

Tinting had been applied to City Hall offices twenty years ago, and recently to
the Community Center offices of the city manager and two other officials, to
control temperature swings, Cotta reported to council, and it will be removed.

It is window film. It is not a scandal and I decline to call it one. It is
simply the miniature: the administration moved into a public building without
asking, and then made the windows harder to see through.

Nobody outside could see in. The reason given to council was temperature
swings. The provision Navickas found does not ask why. It took a former
councilor reading the code to say so out loud, which by now is the pattern
rather than the exception.

## The Verdict

Sabrina Cotta did not crack the rafter. She did not write the 1884 deed, she
did not lose the 2020 bond, and she did not close City Hall, Fire Marshal Shay
did, under independent statutory authority, and Councilor Bloom is right that
this was not discretionary.

Everything after February 17 is hers.

A $6,000 rafter repaired and the goalposts moved to a $260,000 roof. A
$23,778 patch quote sitting in the packet, unremarked. A fire marshal who asked
for an engineer's report on the roof system and got a closure with no end date
instead. A live warranty from a Medford company that had not received a phone
call three months after the council directed action. The April 7 direction that
produced nothing by the end of June. Leaks that keep a building closed and that
public works says have done no significant damage. Five different explanations
for one locked door. A $2 million public building occupied ahead of the public
it was renovated for, with the policy question never brought to the body that
makes policy, and the city manager out of town for the meeting called to discuss
it. Locks that the public's calendar waited on so the government's offices could
keep theirs.

And a police officer in Jim Falkenstein's driveway, ordered by a person the
mayor, the chief and the city manager have each said was not them.

The people who lost here are easy to name. They are the couple who wanted a
wedding reception in the Community Center and could not, for seven years, and
then could not because the government was in it, and then could not because the
locks for the government's offices had not arrived. They are the family who
wanted a memorial in the hall their taxes rebuilt. They are Beth Falkenstein,
who came home from the grocery store to a police car in her driveway because her
husband locked a door the city left open.

Get the engineer's report the fire marshal asked for in February. Call the
roofer. Bring the April 7 bids to council. Give the building back. And name the
person who sent that officer, because a city that will not say who pointed a
police car at a journalist has a problem considerably larger than a rafter.

---

*Sources: Fire Marshal Mark Shay, General Fire Inspection Report, City Hall, 20
E. Main St., Feb. 17, 2026 (City of Ashland Document Center). City Hall Repair
Recommendations and Costing Estimates, as of March 25, 2026, and the Hoag
Roofing proposal of April 24, 2026, both attached to the May 4, 2026 City
Council study session packet (pp. 450-527 of 532). Appraisal of Ashland City
Hall by Colette Meyer, MAI, date of value Feb. 3, 2026, same packet. Ashland
City Council special meeting of March 27, 2026, and regular meetings of April 7
and May 5, 2026, as transcribed from the meeting record. Reporting:
Ashland.news, "Ashland City Hall shuttered over structural concerns after
inspection," Feb. 19, 2026, and "Judge to decide fate of Ashland City Hall deed
as repair costs loom"; OPB / Jefferson Public Radio, "Ashland council votes to
remove city offices from community center," March 31, 2026; The Ashland
Chronicle (David Runkel), "City Hall Tidbits" of Feb. 23, June 1, June 29 and
Aug. 3, 2026, "Ashland Officials Have No Explanation For Community Center Doors
Being Wide Open," May 27, 2026, "Ashland Mayor Escalates City's Complaint
Against Falkenstein," June 3, 2026, and "Ashland City Hall Is Closed
Indefinitely," June 30, 2026. Quotations from meetings are as transcribed;
quotations from documents are as written.*

Source: https://ashlandfreepress.com/opinion/2026-08-04-the-reason-keeps-changing